Valentine's Day Pies

❤️ Perfect for sharing, or for treating yourself! ❤️

Dark chocolate ice cream, sea salt, rich caramel, chocolate crumb crust topped with sweetened crème fraîche & chocolate curls.

Order For Pickup

OUR STORY

The Penny Ice Creamery, founded in Santa Cruz, California, crafts ice cream with love and skill completely from scratch using local, organic and seasonal ingredients grown by farmers we know.

A delicious scoop of ice cream on a hand rolled waffle cone (made fresh in house) topped with toasted marshmallow fluff.

SINCE 2010

A Santa Cruz Original

Founded on the hottest day of the year in 2010, we have been making ice cream from scratch ever since.

Demonstrating our commitment to craft, a Penny team member carefully hand rolls a waffle cone fresh from the waffle cone maker.

#madefromscratch

We take pride in making everything completely from scratch using local, seasonal and organic ingredients.

EVENTS

Catering and More

Private parties, corporate events, weddings and more. The Penny has a history of creating amazing experiences for guests in gatherings ranging from the initmate to assemblies in the thousands.

Book The Penny

Outside on a beautiful sunny day, a friendly Penny employee stands behind our farmers' market stand, with an ice cream scooper at the ready in one hand and holding out a delicious ice cream cone with the other hand..